Orthodox vs Catholic icons
The two churches share more than they differ on. Both accept the Seventh Ecumenical Council on images, and both hold that holy pictures deserve reverence. The differences are in style and habit: an Orthodox icon follows a fixed pattern and is usually flat, while Catholic art has, since the 13th century, had more freedom and realism and often includes statues.
| Orthodox icons | Catholic sacred images | |
|---|---|---|
| The word | Icon, the usual name | Icon is not generally used |
| Style | A fixed pattern, copied within set limits | More freedom and realism since the 13th century |
| Form | Usually two-dimensional | Paintings and also much three-dimensional statuary |
| Saints | Recognized by the Church and glorified | Canonized by the Apostolic See after a long process |
What they share. Wikipedia reports that the Catholic Church accepted the decrees of the Seventh Ecumenical Council on images and, like the Orthodox, holds that holy pictures deserve reverence. Until the 13th century, the sacred images of the West followed Eastern models, in the manner known as Italo-Byzantine.
Why Orthodox icons look alike. OrthodoxWiki describes an iconographer as handing on tradition by reproducing earlier icons inside prescribed bounds, and across most of Church history the makers went unnamed. That is why an icon of Christ painted today resembles one painted long ago.
How the West went another way. After that, Western artists were slowly given more room to be inventive and lifelike. Wikipedia adds that Catholics have long favored statues as well as paintings, and that they stress the role of images as a Bible of the Poor.
Saints. The Catholic Church reserves canonization to the Apostolic See at the end of a long process. In the Orthodox Church, OrthodoxWiki says, believers do not make a saint; they acknowledge someone whom God has already glorified, often in a formal service.
In short. Both venerate sacred images; the Orthodox icon is a flat, traditional pattern, usually anonymous, and Western art has more freedom and many statues.
Honor passes to the one pictured
The Orthodox and the Catholic Church both teach that the reverence shown to an icon is not paid to the wood and paint. In Orthodox practice a person kisses an icon of Christ to show love for Christ, and prays in front of it at home or in church. The icon is not meant to be admired for its artist, which is why most are unsigned. If you wish to know how a particular saint is honored in your community, your parish priest is the person to ask.
Orthodox icons for a prayer corner
The Christ Pantocrator under a gold-tone cover in an arched wooden frame that stands on its own, $69, and the small Pantocrator on a dark wooden board with a stand at the back, $69, are Orthodox icons for a prayer corner, and the folding pair of Christ and the Mother of God, $74, closes like a book.
ΕικόναΟρθόδοξη ξύλινη αναδιπλούμενη εικόνα Ιησούς Χριστός & Παναγία
$106$74
ΕικόναΟρθόδοξη ξύλινη εικόνα Ιησούς Χριστός ο Παντοκράτωρ
Χρυσό χρώμα$99$69
ΕικόναΟρθόδοξη ξύλινη εικόνα Ιησούς Χριστός ο Παντοκράτωρ
Ασημί-χρυσό χρώμα · 12x9 cm$99$69
ΕικόναΟρθόδοξη ξύλινη αναδιπλούμενη εικόνα Χριστός & Παναγία
Ασημί-χρυσό χρώμα$113$79
- Blessing, $49. Blessed by an Orthodox priest before it ships.
- Gift packaging, $20
Questions
Are Orthodox icons the same as Catholic icons?
Not quite. Wikipedia says the word icon is not generally used in Western Christianity, though the Catholic Church accepts the Seventh Ecumenical Council on images and Western art once followed Eastern patterns.
Do Catholics venerate icons?
Wikipedia says Catholics agree with the Orthodox that holy pictures deserve reverence, and that they have also favored statues, which are less common in the East.
How do Orthodox and Catholic saints differ?
Both churches venerate saints. The Catholic Church canonizes through the Apostolic See after a long process, while OrthodoxWiki says the Orthodox Church acknowledges people God has already glorified.
Why are Orthodox icons usually unsigned?
OrthodoxWiki describes the iconographer’s work as handing on tradition, so across most of Church history the makers went unnamed.